Media as a scholarly source of information: evidence from legal theses and dissertations

Keywords: Theses and dissertations, legal education, media, Newspapers, Magazines, Television and Radio

Abstract

This study sought to determine the citation of media sources by law students in South Africa. Data were gathered from theses and dissertations of selected law schools in the country using specifically designed excel spreadsheets comprising columns for citations and sources, among others. The results, in relation to the research questions of the study, indicate that media, as a source of information, was the least cited while other secondary sources of information such as journal articles and books were among the most cited sources. Regarding usage of the media, the results show that newspapers had a high citation rate, followed by Television, radio, with magazines coming last. The study findings further indicate that two African economic giants, South Africa and Nigeria, were among the top origin of the media cited, alongside the United Kingdom, and the United States of America. The results further indicate that the Mail and Guardian, the British Broadcasting Corporation, and the Economist magazine, were the most cited forms of media. The study also indicates a positive but weak relationship between scholarly (citation) and public impact (circulation) of media sources.

References

Abalaka, B.F., Yahaya, D. & Okikiri, M.N. 2014. Acquisition and preservation of newspapers and magazines in Dr. Aliyu Obaje Library, Kogi State University Anyigba. Journal of Human Ecology, 45(3): 251-255.

Akanda, A.K.M.E.A. & Haque, M.D.A. 2013. Newspaper reading habits of university graduate students in Bangladesh: a case study. IMPACT: International Journal of Research in Applied, Natural and Social Sciences, 1(3): 1-8.

Alabi, S.O. 2015. organization and use of newspapers in two Nigerian private university libraries. Elk Asia Pacific Journal of Library Management and Information Technology, 1(2): 18-30.

Anderson, P.S., Odom, A.R., Gray, H.M., Jones, J.B., Christensen, W. F., Hollingshead, T., Hadfield, J. G., Evans-Pickett, A., Frost, M., Wilson, C., Davidson, L.E. & Seeley, M. K. 2020. A case study exploring associations between popular media attention of scientific research and scientific citations. PLoS ONE, 15(7): e0234912. [Online]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0234912. (06 June 2021).

Biber, K. 2019. Dignity in the digital age: Broadcasting the Oscar Pistorius trial. Crime Media Culture, 15(3) 401–422.

Bischoff, K. 2014. Social Media Discovery. Bench & Bar of Minnesota, 71(8): 64. [Online]. https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=lgs&AN=108692000&site=ehost-live&scope=site. (22 April 2021).

Channaptna, K., & Awari, V. H. 2015. Newspaper Reading Habits among Post-Graduate Students of Karnatak University, Dharwad. DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology, 35(1).

Chowdhury, S., & Halder, S. 2016. Educational Dissemination through Newspaper Daily. Journal of Education and Practice, 7(7), 1-12.

Church, J. 1998. Legal Education in South Africa-An Historical Overview. Fundamina, 4, 108.

Dumas‑Mallet, E., Garenne, A., Boraud, T. & Gonon, F. 2020. Does newspapers coverage influence the citations count of scientific publications? An analysis of biomedical studies. Scientometrics, 123(1):413–427.

du Plessis, M. 2019. Forty-five years of clinical legal education in South Africa. Fundamina, 25(2): 12-34.

Ejima, S. O. 2014. Contribution of Nigerian online newspapers to public health education in Nigeria: A content analysis of selected Nigerian newspapers. International Journal of Basic and Applied Science, 3(2): 74-81.

Fanelli, D. 2013. Any publicity is better than none: newspaper coverage increases citations, in the UK more than in Italy. Scientometrics, 95 (3):1167–1177.

Freeland, M. & Bailey, M. (2008). Print newspapers: are they still being used in academic and research libraries? Serials Librarian, 55(1-2): 210-226.

Gellert, G. A. 2019. Fake medical news: the ethics and dangers of health product advertising disguised as real news. Online Journal of Health Ethics, 15(2): 1-11.

Greenbaum, L. 2009. A history of the racial disparities in legal education in South Africa. John Marshall Law Journal, 3(1): 1-19.

Gumede, W. 2014. South Africa's media and the strengthening of democracy: 20 years of democracy. Rhodes Journalism Review, 1(34): 7–10.

Hutchinson, T., & Duncan, N. 2012. Defining and describing what we do: Doctrinal legal research. Deakin Law Review, 17(1):83–119.

Igbeka, J. U., & Ola, C. O. 2010. Use of newspapers by Nigerian university students: The case of Delta State University, Anwai campus. Library philosophy and practice. [Online]. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/358/. (22 April 2021).

Iroaganachi, M.A., Itsekor, V., & Osinulu, I. 2014. Citation analysis of social science research: A case study of bachelor degree research project reports of a Nigerian university 2009–2013. Library Philosophy and Practice. [Online]. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/109. (22 April 2021).

Jones, A. 2009. The many uses of newspapers. Tufts University. [Online]. http://dlxs. richmond. edu/d/ddr/docs/papers/usesofnewspapers. pdf. (02 April 2021).

Kobusingye, C. (2016). Access and use of newspapers at Makerere University Library. Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Libraries, 5(3), 721-736.

Kousha, K. and Thelwall, M. 2017. News stories as evidence for research? BBC citations from articles, books, and Wikipedia. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 68(8): 2017–2028.

Krtalic, M. & Hasenay, D. 2012. Newspapers as a source of scientific information in social sciences and humanities: a case study of Faculty of Philosophy, University of Osijek, Croatia. In World Library and Information Congress, 78th IFLA General Conference and Assembly. [Online]. http://conference.ifla.org/past-wlic/2012/119-krtalic-en.pdf. (02 April 2021).

Liebler, R., & Liebert, J. (2012). Something Rotten in the State of Legal Citation: The Life Span of a United States Supreme Court Citation Containing an Internet Link (1996-2010). Yale JL & Tech., 15, 273.

Meyer, E. T. 2018. The scholarly impacts of newspapers: the Guardian, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and New York Times. Oxford: Oxford University Consulting. [Online]. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3194632. (10 May 2021).

Mlambo, J.P. 2014. Multichoice (Proprietary) Limited and Others v National Prosecuting Authority and Another. Pretoria: Gauteng High Court.

Njeze, M. E. (2013). Use of newspapers and magazines in the academic pursuits of university students: Case study of Covenant University. Library philosophy and practice, 845, 467-478.

Nobles, R., & Schiff, D. 2004. A story of miscarriage: law in the media. Journal of Law and Society, 31(2): 221-244.

Palamar, J.J. & Strain, E.C. 2021. News and social media coverage is associated with more downloads and citations of manuscripts that focus on substance use. Drug and Alcohol Dependence (Ahead of Print), 218.

Ravikumar, S & Agrahari, A. 2015. Flow of Information from dailies to Periodicals: A Citation Analysis. In: Emerging Trends and Issues in Scientometrics, Informetrics and Webometrics. New Delhi: Ane Books, pp.48-58.

Singh, A. J. & Ravikumar, S. 2018a. Newspaper Citation in Scholarly Publications: A Study on Financial Times Newspaper during 2001-2010 as reflected in Web of Science. Library Philosophy and Practice, 1-50.

Singh, A. J. & Ravikumar, S. 2018b. Mapping the Citation flow of New York Times Newspaper indexed in Web of Science. Library Philosophy and Practice, 1-23.

Tiwari, S.K. 2018. The role of media in spreading legal awareness. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities, 1(5): 1-10.

Ugah, A. D. 2009. Strategies for preservation and increased access to newspapers in Nigerian university libraries. Library philosophy and practice.

Van Rooyens, J.C.W. 2011. SABC 3 vs Mail and Guardian and Sam Sole. Broadcasting Johannesburg: Complaints Commission of South Africa. [Online]. https://www.bccsa.co.za/2015/03/13/case-no-052011-mail-and-guardian-media-limited-and-sole-vs-sabc3-and-safm-news/. (23 May 2021).

Wasserman, H. 2020. The state of South African media: a space to contest democracy. Publizistik, 65(3): 451–465.

Wikipedia. 2021. Financial Times. [Online]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_Times. (23 May 2021).

Zago, S. D. 2005. Secondary Source

Published
2022-09-15
Section
Research Articles